Alan Gleeson

A deep dive into the comparison between open-back and closed-back headphones. Although there are thousands of different headphone models, they all share one design aspect– they are either open-back or closed-back. Figuring out which design best suits your needs can be frustrating, especially when you know very little about each design. However, by closely comparing the two designs, you can settle on the one that best suits your needs. This article dives into a detailed comparison between the two designs to help you determine which type would work best for you. Read on! Open-Back vs. Closed-Back Headphones: What’s the Difference? So what is the fundamental difference between closed-back and open-back headphones? Should you buy closed- or open-back headphones? Let’s quickly discuss each type below to help you understand what you should be looking for below. What are open-back headphones? When we describe headphones as open-back, it means the outward-facing backs of the ear cups are left open for airflow. As a result, the inside of the ear cups is exposed to the environment, letting the sound flow into your ears and the space around you. The benefit of open-back headphones is that the music you’re playing can interact with the room around you, leaving your hearing unobstructed. Professionals and audiophiles often use them because they have a clearer, more immersive, and more realistic sound. However, this exclusivity does often make them more expensive than closed-back headphones. Unfortunately, open-back headsets leak sound because they're open to the environment. This can be inconvenient in public, making them a lousy choice for managing private calls. What are closed-back headphones? Closed-back headphones are headphones with airtight ear cups. This encloses the sound, leading to a sealed listening experience. With a closed-back headset, nobody will be able to hear your audio. However, your hearing will also be muffled. This makes closed-back headphones more commercially popular (and therefore often cheaper) as most people want to keep their listening private. As a result, closed-back headphones are more accessible in different models, sizes, and colors. Open-Back and Closed-Back Headphones: Which Is Better? Now you know the technical differences between open- and closed-back headphones. But which is better suited to your needs? Let’s look at how the design difference affects the functionality of these headphones and your listening experience. Bass response Soundstage Sound leakage Noise isolation Versatility Price Comfort Bass response. Closed-back headphones usually produce deeper and punchier bass. Because the sound is sealed into the ear cups, it can resonate through the material and funnel directly into your ear, like a bubble around your head, enclosing the sound. This boosted bass is called the proximity effect– when the source of a sound is closer to the receiver, the bass gets lower and louder. However, this can also result in a bass build-up. This is when the bass gets too strong and bothersome, often muddying the mids and treble frequencies. Open-back headphones, on the other hand, often struggle to produce a full bass frequency. By allowing unrestricted airflow into your ear and out of the headphones, they lose the resonation and vibration, resulting in a powerful and punchy bass. This causes a roll-off in their lower frequencies, which often leaves the bass lacking. If you’re enthusiastic about the bass in your music, then closed-back headphones will produce a more fitting sound quality for you. Soundstage. The soundstage of an audio track refers to the ability of the track to create a perception of space within the music. This happens through the separation between the layers of music that results in the feeling of depth. When it comes to soundstage, open-back headphones are the clear winner. This is because they allow sound to escape into the space around you. As a result, the music you hear sounds like a part of your surrounding. Open headphones allow the sound to interact with the room around you, which leads to a spacious soundstage and a more realistic listening experience– a bit like being at a live concert, where the instruments and vocals resonate in the environment. This results in clearer and more natural sound quality without feeling trapped in a bubble, like when using closed-back headphones. The expanded soundstage and immersive listening are why professionals and audiophiles often prefer open-back headphones. In contrast, closed-back headphones trap the sound within their ear cups, limiting the acoustic interaction of the track with the environment and constricting the soundstage. Sound leakage. Sound leakage refers to how sound escapes your headphones and becomes audible to the people around you. Unsurprisingly, closed-back headphones are far better at preventing sound leakage. Most closed-back headphones will keep your audio private unless you’re blasting music at top volume. Open-back headphones are, by design, much worse at preventing sound leakage. They are loud enough for those around you to hear, even at lower volumes. There’s no way to avoid this with open-back headphones because if the openings are blocked off to prevent sound leakage, they’ll simply become closed-back headphones! If you’re in private, the sound leakage from open-back headphones shouldn’t be a problem. Noise isolation. Noise isolation, or passive noise cancellation, is when the material of the headphones in your ears blocks ambient sound. A high environmental noise can disrupt your listening experience, so you’ll likely prefer good noise cancellation. Again, the closed-back headphones triumph here. Because there is a seal around your ears, the sound won’t creep in as easily, and you’ll be more closed off from the disruptive outside world. Open-back headphones can’t block out ambient sound very well. Because they have openings in the back of the ear cups, the environmental sound isn’t obstructed by as much material. This can be useful if you want to hear what’s happening around you: if you’re walking near a road or participating in a conversation, you will need clearer hearing. However, in most situations, the noise isolation ability of closed-back headphones will be more handy. Versatility. Versatility is the headphones’ ability to adapt to different functions and situations. So, unless you’re buying headphones for use in only one situation and environment, versatility is an important factor in their overall usability. In general, closed-back headphones are the most versatile option. They’re better at passive noise cancellation so that you can hear your audio better in louder places, and use them in public without annoying anyone. Not only are they the most useable option in most situations, they are also the design of the most produced headphones. This gives you more options when it comes to size and style. If you can only get one pair of headphones, closed-back headphones are the best versatile option. However, if you’re buying headphones specifically for studio listening or private at-home use, versatility won’t be such an important factor. In this case, you should base your decision on other factors like sound quality and comfort. Price. In general, open-back headphones are more expensive than closed-back. This is because most open-back headphones have a better sound quality. They’re often designed for experienced producers and artists, and those deeply passionate about their music. Usually, this means that the price is higher for a more professional product. Closed-back headphones, on the hand, are designed for the larger market, so they tend to be available at a lower range of price points. However, this is a generalization based on the current market of high-end headphones, which leans towards open-backs. There are cheap open-back headphones out there as well– like the or the , available for under $100. There are also plenty of expensive closed-back headphones, like the or the , available for over $500. However, the more expensive closed-back headphones usually have more features and functions, like active noise cancellation, exceptional sound performance, or specialized materials like DLC (diamond-like coating). When it comes to cost, you will get a wide range of prices, varying from brand to brand and model to model. However, you can expect to spend a little more when choosing open-back headphones. Comfort. Comfort is always an essential factor in headphones, especially if you plan to use them for a long time. There are several factors that determine how comfortable your listening experience is, such as: The size of the ear cups Their adjustability in rotation and extension The clamping force of the headband. The materials used for cushioning. Fit. Of course, style and fit are always subjective. Some people prefer a tighter fit, larger ear cups, or firmer cushioning than others. In these aspects, you probably won’t have issues with either design. Although fewer models of open-back headphones are available on the market, most are similar if not identical in fit to the average closed-back headphones. Unless you have a unique head shape and size that needs a niche design, you should find most headphones to fit you comfortably. Unfortunately, if you experience issues with headphone fit, you have fewer open-back options. Breathability. An often overlooked facet of comfort in headphones is breathability. If you wear big, airtight cups over your ears for hours, they can get hot, sweaty, and stifling. In this aspect, open-back headphones are the obvious winner. The openings in the cups dissipate heat rapidly and cycle air throughout the ear cups, leading to a more open and breathable design. Overall, comfort is a subjective experience. In general, you’ll likely find open-back headphones to be more comfortable over longer periods due to their breathability, but there isn’t a major difference in fit...

Read More from Alan Gleeson