PSA: Reports of AirPods Scams From Major Retailers Are Rising

Users have reported receiving used, fake, or tampered electronics from Walmart, Costco, and Target.
Users have reported receiving used, fake, or tampered electronics from Walmart, Costco, and Target.

We independently review all our recommendations. Purchases made via our links may earn us a commission. Learn more ❯

These big box retailers are allegedly selling fakes and getting involved in wide tech scams.

If you’re in the market for a new pair of AirPods, you might want to think twice before heading to Walmart, Costco, or Target. Recent Reddit posts have revealed a troubling trend of customers receiving fake or tampered products when purchasing AirPods and other devices from these retailers.

Walmart and Costco’s Electronics Dilemma

ParkerApplejax' original post on r/Scams. (From: Reddit)
ParkerApplejax’ original post on r/Scams. (From: Reddit)

Reddit user ParkerApplejax shared that he bought AirPods from Walmart but realized they were fake as they had no serial number.

When he tried to return them, the Walmart staff allegedly said they had a policy against returning Apple products. They recommended he go to an Apple Store instead.

However, the Apple employee told him to return the product to Walmart.

“I went to the Apple Store to confirm that they were indeed fake (no serial number along with 10 other issues. They broke in half when I pulled the ear tip off for the first time as well).” he shares.

“The Apple employee confirmed they were fake and said “yeah you would need the order number etc. So you would return them at Walmart, just like any other Walmart purchase”.”

On his second return to Walmart, he was denied again, even though his receipt showed a 30-day return policy for electronics. It was only after he mentioned involving a lawyer that Walmart refunded him.

“Finally, I said ‘how about you tell me that in writing, and I can get my lawyer involved. These AirPods are fake.’ Not another word was spoken, I got my refund in seconds.” he says.
Reddit user ParkerApplejax was told by Walmart staff they had a policy against returning Apple products. (From: Reddit)
Reddit user ParkerApplejax was told by Walmart staff they had a policy against returning Apple products. (From: Reddit)

Similarly, Redditor Logical-Pie918 had trouble with an online order from Costco.

His AirPods arrived with the outer package sealed, but the AirPods’ box itself was open. Inside the box was a coil nut instead of a pair of AirPods.

Redditor Logical-Pie918 received a coil nut instead of AirPods. (From: Reddit)
Redditor Logical-Pie918 received a coil nut instead of AirPods. (From: Reddit)

Costco offered a refund. However, the user remains concerned about a second order (an iPad) that is scheduled to arrive.

“I’m wondering: how common is this? I also ordered an iPad that’s supposed to be delivered tomorrow. Not sure if I should open it in front of my doorbell camera or even bring it to a warehouse and open it there in front of customer service. I’m spooked by this if you can’t tell.” he says.

Prevalence of the Issue

Return fraud is supposedly a big problem at retail stores. (From: Reddit)
Return fraud is supposedly a big problem at retail stores. (From: Reddit)

The experiences shared by many other Reddit users suggest that receiving fake or tampered electronics is not a one-time thing.

Many customers have also reported similar incidents when buying high-value items like AirPods, iPads, gaming consoles, and other electronics from major retailers. They shared experiences of receiving opened boxes or missing parts when purchasing from retailers like Amazon and Target.

“Half of the stuff I order from Amazon comes with a clearly opened box and sometimes missing things like instructions or other small things that you don’t really know are missing if you don’t know the product.” one user mentioned.

According to a Target employee, scammers can easily rewrap items to make them look unopened. This makes it hard for retailers to spot tampered products. A Target employee mentioned that they have to open expensive returned items to confirm the contents. Opened items are not resold even if they are the correct product.

In his one experience, a buyer got an Xbox from Target that turned out to be a box filled with books.

Many other users shared similar experiences.

Employees sharing their experiences with return fraud. (From: Reddit)
Employees sharing their experiences with return fraud. (From: Reddit)

Some users also reported receiving used or broken items when buying electronics from retailers.

A user allegedly got a used controller from Target. (From: Reddit)
A user allegedly got a used controller from Target. (From: Reddit)

Potential Causes: Scammers and Distribution Chain Theft

According to the users, the issue seems to come from two main sources: return fraud by scammers and theft by employees in the distribution chain.

Some Reddit users believe that the problems come from widespread return fraud, not dishonest employees. Scammers allegedly buy real products, replace them with fake or inferior items, and then return the package for a refund. The fake products are then resold to unsuspecting customers.

“The employees weren’t in on it. There’s a large amount of return fraud to retailers like Walmart. They started getting lots of people returning fake AirPods and keeping the originals. That’s why they tried to deny you. They thought you were scamming them,” says OkRickySpinach.

According to a former Walmart employee, some workers also struggle to spot these scams. As a result, they unknowingly accept tampered items and put them back on the shelves for resale.

Walmart employees are allegedly not trained well enough to spot the scams. (From: Reddit)
Walmart employees are allegedly not trained well enough to spot the scams. (From: Reddit)

Theft by employees in the distribution chain, particularly those working for shipping companies like UPS, has also been identified as a contributing factor by some users.

In some cases, workers have allegedly been caught stealing high-value items from packages. They replace them with other objects before resealing the packages.

“The scariest thing is these scams have chiefly been the same as those you experienced. Meaning, somebody along the distribution chain swapped the genuine item for a counterfeit.” RudbeckiaIS noted.

A recent example is a case where a former UPS worker was caught stealing Apple products from a warehouse and selling them on Kijiji. Other users also shared similar stories involving employees from UPS, FedEx, and even USPS supposedly tampering with mail and packages.

Comments from users discussing how scams can happen before products reach stores. (From: Reddit)
Comments from users discussing how scams can happen before products reach stores. (From: Reddit)

The thread mentions how standards vary among superstores like Walmart and Costco. One Redditor said it leads to inconsistencies in store policies and how employees are trained.

“Walmart stores (sadly) vary wildly in their operational quality. Which is to say some have managers squeezing max bonuses by deflecting returns to other stores, using poorly trained associates, and otherwise being a circus. Others will follow the policy and smart procedures, including double and triple checking returns before restocking those that should even be eligible.” said Euchre.
Comments from users sharing their bad experiences ordering from big box retail stores. (From: Reddit)
Comments from users sharing their bad experiences ordering from big box retail stores. (From: Reddit)

Tips for Buying Expensive Electronics Safely

Checking a product's security seal is one way to see if it's been tampered with. (From: Reddit)
Checking a product’s security seal is one way to see if it’s been tampered with. (From: Reddit)

To avoid risks when buying high-value electronics, consumers are advised to purchase them from the manufacturer whenever possible.

But, if buying from a third-party retailer is necessary, some Redditors suggested these tips to ensure you get genuine, undamaged items:

  • Ship to Store: Send your items to a nearby store for pickup. This lets you check the product with store staff immediately after receiving it.
  • Open at the Counter: Open the product at the store counter or in front of your home’s doorbell camera. This records how the item looks when you first get it.
  • Check the Security Seal: Always look at a product’s seal before you leave the store to ensure your item is untampered. High-value items, like Apple products, have a seal that tells you if someone has opened the box.

💬 Conversation: 1 comment

  1. A lot of these theft, problems and other problems that we have today concerning money, could be solved and answered with just one question… Who did you vote for?? Ding, ding, ding, there’s your answer!!

Leave a Reply